Friday, April 30, 2010

Inikah ketua polis yang anda harapkan?

Ketua Polis Negara, Tan Sri Musa Hassan membidas kritikan pelbagai pihak berhubung kematian remaja berusia 14 tahun - Aminulrasyid Amzah dan berkata beliau sedia mengarahkan anggotanya supaya tidak lagi mengawal jika itu kehendak rakyat.

"Biarlah apa yang nak dikatakan oleh ahli politik, tapi saya ingin tahu sama ada anda mahu kami menguatkuasakan undang-udnang atau tidak.

"Kalau tak nak, saya akan beritahu orang saya supaya tidak lagi menahan kereta yang dipandu dengan cara mencurigakan atau mengambil tindakan terhadap pelumba haram yang bermaharajalela di jalan raya," katanya dalam laporan The Star online

*******

Inilah contoh betapa kita sangat tidak rasional. Sangat mengecewakan apabila ia keluar dari mulut seorang ketua polis. Langsung tidak profesional. Kalau En. Ketua Polis tak faham lagi, rakyat bukan mempersoalkan tugas, rakyat mempersoalkan tindakan. Katakan terdapat seorang guru merotan pelajarnya hingga mati, dan tindakan guru itu dikecam dan dikritik, adakah patut guru-guru lain tidak lagi dedikasi dengan tugasnya? atau pengarah JPM berkata,

"Biarlah apa yang nak dikatakan oleh ahli politik, tapi saya ingin tahu sama ada anda mahu kami mendidik anak-anak anda atau tidak.

"Kalau tak nak, saya akan beritahu orang saya supaya tidak lagi mendidik pelajar dengan ikhlas dan jujur, biarkan sahaja anak murid mahu jadi bodoh, perompak atau penyamun dan gagal dalam SPM."


________________

*orang saya? peh, macam gangster.


9 comments:

Anonymous said...

The IGP is an embarrassment. No wonder the police force is so fucked up. He needs to resign like yesterday!

mukhsen_x said...

So uncivilized statement! as Malaysian, i'm not only ashamed, but feel unsecured to have him as IGP. He should resign!

Anonymous said...

I am ashamed of you, Mukhsen. The boy Aminulrasyid drove a car WITHOUT a bloody license. Then tries to run away AND ram into people. He deserved to be punished, and unfortunately, death came when he least expected.
Don't you all go and blame the police. He chose to drive at 2 am when other school kids are sleeping. he chose to drive without a license. He chose avoid and ram the police, THUS he chose to break the law. Now he DIES with the decisions he choses.
Under the law (in any parts of the world), the police has EVERY RIGHT to shoot and kill those who acted to injury or kill the people. There are already cctv footage that showed what happened that night. Go and see the footage and stop blaming the police. You are weak since are emotionally attached to this boy. Look at the evidences before you judge something.

Taf Teh said...

;-0

Police has to do the dirty job of patrolling uncivilized citizens who cross the civilized line...

mukhsen_x said...

Basically in my belief, every life is worth to be killed, even police them self or criminals. I don’t blame police as whole, I have good friends who were police and I believe they done a very great job.

Yes, my point of view is a prejudgment, I don’t know what the exactly situation on the time that the shoot happened. But in my opinion, whatever situation; there have other option besides shooting.

If police shoot because he rammed the car to them in reverse, I don’t think that the cop who shoots is sitting behind the car, but beside the car. But if he really behind the car, he still can jump to the safety side.

But sadly, the police choose to shoot.

What if maybe, the shoot is accidently went to the boy while police trying to stop the car. I think there’s a lot of other option to stop car without shooting. But sadly, the police choose to shoot.
Why?

That because what the anon (I think he is a cop, or maybe has a family who were cop) tell us.

-Under the law (in any parts of the world), the police has EVERY RIGHT to shoot and kill those who acted to injury or kill the people.

This EVERY RIGHT has made them right, so they choose to shoot. Oh, hold on! I think that not true. I think there must have a procedure before it has done right? I should not just like that that u can shoot and kill. Damd! I hold up my comment, I want to check first. Really anon? they have EVERY RIGHT? But there must have a procedure, right?

mukhsen_x said...

But I'm really feel ashamed of the IGP reaction on the critics. Even if he wants to say it to opposition politician leaders, he must understand that those politicians were also rakyat, and have their supporters who was also rakyat. For example, if that same IGP statement is to be direct just to one person, that still a very unprofessional statement.

mukhsen_x said...

I can't complaint about dirty job, that happened anywhere. But basically, absolute power, corrupt absolutely. And no power comes no responsibility. :P

fadz said...

weird untuk anon, dalam hal biasa, malah dalam FILEM, bila penjenayah tembak, baharu polis tembak balas (kecuali polis2 yg panas, macam filem LA Confidential).. di sini, adakah budak tu tembak polis sehingga patut ditembak balas? adakah "menembak" the last resort untuk tutup perangai "jahat" budak tu? Apa yg budak tu buat, bunuh orang atau mengelak dan tidak sengaja menyusahkan org yg boleh membawa maut? Semua itu perlu diambil konsiderasi..

serius.. bila IGP cakap macam tu, walaupun mungkin dia betul, org akan lihat SELURUH pihak polis (walaupun secara generalisasi aku percaya tak) ini berperangai samseng, dan itu menyedihkan..

mukhsen_x said...

ya, even dalam filem, walaupun suspek itu bersenjata, polis akan meminta supaya senjata itu dijatuhkan dahulu. Hanya apabila suspek mengangkat senjata dan mengacukan kepada polis, barulah tembakan dilepaskan, dan saya kira banyak contoh apabila tembakan dilepaskan polis, ianya tidak dengan tujuan membunuh.

Bagi saya, perkara paling penting, setiap nyawa sangat tinggi nilainya walaupun penjenayah paling ganas sekalipun. Sekurang-kurangnya dia punya peluang untuk memohon ampun kepada Tuhan, sebelum kita menghukumnya, contohnya digantung sampai mati.

Dalam pada itu, saya tidak menafikan tugas polis sangat mencabar terutamanya dalam menghadapi penjenayah, bagaimana dia mahu melindungi nyawa orang awam dan dalam masa yang sama nyawanyanya sendiri. Saya sangat hormat kepada polis yang sanggup meletakkan nyawanya sendiri sebagai pertaruhan antara penjenayah dan orang awam. Hanya persoalan kita, bagaimana prosuder yang sebaiknya semoga apa yang menimpa Aminulrasyid tidak lagi berulang.